Bitcompare Community

Cover image for CertiK Clears up Extortion Allegations as Kraken Recovers $3M
Margaret Boucher
Margaret Boucher

Posted on

CertiK Clears up Extortion Allegations as Kraken Recovers $3M

Cryptocurrency exchange Kraken and blockchain security firm CertiK have resolved a contentious dispute over a $3 million bug bounty payout. The saga began on June 9th when an anonymous security researcher reported a critical vulnerability to Kraken that allowed attackers to artificially increase their account balances.

Kraken's Chief Security Officer Nicholas Percoco revealed that the researcher and their team exploited the bug to withdraw over $3 million from Kraken's treasury. Percoco accused the researchers of extortion, stating they refused to return the funds unless Kraken provided a speculative payout based on the potential damage the vulnerability could have caused.

However, CertiK has now come forward and identified itself as the security firm involved. CertiK claimed that after reporting the vulnerability, Kraken's security team threatened its employees and demanded they "repay a mismatched amount of crypto in an unreasonable time even without providing repayment addresses."

CertiK maintained that its actions were in line with standard white hat hacking practices, where researchers disclose vulnerabilities to companies in exchange for bug bounty rewards. The firm asserted that withdrawing the funds was necessary to demonstrate the severity of the flaw to Kraken.

Ultimately, CertiK and Kraken have now resolved the dispute, with Kraken confirming it has recovered the $3 million in stolen assets, minus transaction fees. This resolution likely involved negotiations between the two parties to reach a mutually agreeable outcome.

The incident highlights the complexities that can arise in the world of bug bounty programs and responsible disclosure. While Kraken was understandably upset about the loss of funds, CertiK argued its actions were motivated by a desire to improve Kraken's security, not to extort the exchange.

This saga also underscores the importance of clear communication and established protocols between security researchers and the companies they work with. Ambiguity around bug bounty rewards and the appropriate steps for demonstrating vulnerabilities can lead to confrontational situations like this one.

Moving forward, both Kraken and CertiK will likely review their bug bounty policies and procedures to prevent similar disputes from occurring in the future. The crypto industry as a whole may also benefit from developing more standardized guidelines for responsible disclosure to foster better collaboration between security researchers and the companies they aim to protect.

Overall, the resolution of this issue, with Kraken recovering the majority of the stolen funds, represents a positive outcome for the security of the cryptocurrency ecosystem. It demonstrates that even in the face of contentious disagreements, constructive dialogue and compromise can lead to satisfactory resolutions.

Top comments (1)

leach profile image

How do you think this will impact future bug bounty practices in the crypto world?